The Madhya Pradesh High Court at Jabalpur has set aside the removal of a police constable who was dismissed over the non-disclosure of two criminal cases in his recruitment documents, despite having been acquitted years before his appointment. Justice Vivek Kumar Singh held that the punishment was arbitrary and disproportionate, considering the nature of the cases, the circumstances of the disclosure and the constable’s service record. The Court directed his reinstatement with continuity of service and consequential benefits, while denying actual back wages.
Background
The petitioner had applied for recruitment as a constable in 2011. Two criminal cases had been registered against him in 2003 and 2006, when he was a teenager and college student. He was acquitted in both cases in 2005 and 2008, respectively.
Although he disclosed a preventive proceeding in his 2011 attestation form, he did not separately mention the two criminal cases. Following character verification, he was appointed on May 30, 2011, and served for more than a decade, receiving 119 rewards and one minor censure.
Departmental proceedings were initiated in 2020, and he was removed from service on November 24, 2021. The appellate authority subsequently ordered his reinstatement with a reduced penalty. However, the Additional Director General of Police reversed that relief in April 2022, restoring his removal. His mercy appeal was also rejected, prompting him to approach the High Court.
Justice Vivek Kumar Singh examined the Supreme Court’s ruling in Ravindra Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh, which requires authorities to assess each case on its individual circumstances rather than automatically treating every non-disclosure as fatal to employment.
The Court observed:
“The vexed question is back again. Is it a hard-and-fast and a cut-and-dried rule that, in all circumstances, non-disclosure of a criminal case (in which the candidate is acquitted) in the verification form is fatal for the candidate’s employment? We think not and it ought not to be so too.”
The judgment noted that both cases involved minor offences and had ended in acquittals before the petitioner’s recruitment. It also considered that he had acknowledged previous legal proceedings in his attestation form and that the local police had cleared his character verification in 2011.
On the question of punishment, the Court emphasised that the authorities were required to assess the circumstances objectively.
It further observed:
“Each case will depend on the facts and circumstances that prevail thereon, and the court will have to take a holistic view, based on objective criteria, with the available precedents serving as a guide. It can never be a one size fits all scenario.”
The Court also considered the petitioner’s decade-long service record and the fact that the revisional proceedings began shortly after the appellate authority had ordered his reinstatement.
Finding the impugned orders arbitrary and disproportionate, the High Court quashed the revisional show-cause notice dated March 21, 2022, the removal order dated April 4, 2022, and the Director General of Police’s order dated July 4, 2022.
The Court directed the State authorities to reinstate Nandkishore Lilhare forthwith as a constable. He was granted continuity of service and notional and consequential benefits, including pay fixation, increments and seniority.
However, he was held not entitled to actual back wages for the period he remained out of service.
Case Details
Case Title: Nandkishore Lilhare v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Others
Case Number: Writ Petition No. 10238 of 2023
Judge: Justice Vivek Kumar Singh
Decision Date: October 28, 2026




