The Supreme Court on November 2 dismissed the appeals of a Maharashtra man and his brother against their convictions in a 1996 dowry-related death case. A Bench of Justice Sandeep Mehta and Justice Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya upheld the Bombay High Court’s judgment, which had convicted the husband of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment.
Background
Vimalbai married Ramkishan Digambar Jadhav on 12 May 1995. The prosecution said she was harassed soon after the wedding over demands for a television, a tape deck, a plot of land and Rs. 50,000 in cash. She died at her matrimonial home on 1 February 1996, within nine months of the marriage.
Her brother Narayan lodged the complaint. Before that, Ramkishan had told the police that his wife became giddy during intimacy and died. The post-mortem gave the cause of death as “asphyxia due to throttling”.
The trial court convicted Ramkishan, his father Digambar and his brother Venkat under Sections 498-A (cruelty by husband or relatives) and 304-B (dowry death) read with Section 34 of the IPC, but acquitted all accused of murder. The High Court later set aside Ramkishan’s acquittal and convicted him under Section 302. Digambar died during the appeal, so the appeal concerning him abated.
The appellants argued that the case rested on circumstantial evidence with a broken chain. Ramkishan’s counsel said Vimalbai died of a sudden epileptic seizure. The counsel for Digambar and Venkat said they had been named only because of their family ties, and sought parity with the relatives acquitted earlier. The State said the death occurred in the husband’s exclusive company and that Section 106 of the Evidence Act required him to explain it.
The Bench noted that the doctor who conducted the post-mortem found neck injuries, including a fractured hyoid bone, and rejected the idea that an epileptic fit could cause them. On the husband’s duty to explain the death, the Court said:
“The failure of the appellant-Ramkishan to furnish a plausible explanation and in discharging the burden cast upon him by virtue of Section 106 of the Evidence Act coupled with the introduction of a false defence, provides an additional incriminating link that completes the chain of circumstantial evidence, and thereby establishing his guilt for the offence of murder punishable under Section 302 of the IPC.”
On the timing of the death, the Court recorded:
“The deceased-Vimalbai was married to the appellant-Ramkishan on 12th May, 1995. She was strangulated and done to death inside the matrimonial home in the early hours of 1st February, 1996 i.e., within approximately nine months of her marriage (and well within the statutory period of seven years prescribed under Section 304-B of the IPC).”
The Court also relied on the testimony of Narayan, the couple’s relatives and two neighbours about beatings, starvation and threats linked to dowry demands. It held the accused had failed to rebut the presumption under Section 113-B of the Evidence Act.
Finding no reason to interfere, the Bench dismissed both appeals. It then directed:
“During the pendency of the present appeals, the appellants had been released on bail. As a consequence of the dismissal of the appeals, the bail bonds executed by them stand cancelled, and they are directed to surrender before the trial Court concerned within a period of four weeks from today to serve out the remaining period of their sentences, failing which the trial Court shall take all necessary steps, including the issuance of non-bailable warrants, to secure their arrest and take them into custody.”




