Logo

70:30 GST Formula Cannot Be Compulsorily Applied Retrospectively to Solar Power Projects Before January 2019: Supreme Court

CB News Desk
Add Court Book as a preferred source on Google

Supreme Court sets aside ₹53.35 crore GST demand against Sterling and Wilson, ruling that the 70:30 valuation formula cannot be imposed retrospectively. - M/s. Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India and Others

70:30 GST Formula Cannot Be Compulsorily Applied Retrospectively to Solar Power Projects Before January 2019: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has ruled that the 70:30 GST valuation formula for solar power generating systems cannot be made mandatory for transactions undertaken before January 1, 2019. Setting aside a GST demand of over ₹53.35 crore against M/s. Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd., the Court held that the GST authorities had wrongly treated an optional tax mechanism as compulsory for the earlier period. The dispute concerned the company's supply and installation of solar power generating systems between July 2017 and December 2018. The Bench also examined whether such solar installations could be classified as immovable property merely because they were attached to civil foundations.

Background

The dispute arose after the CGST authorities issued an order dated January 17, 2025, demanding additional GST from Sterling and Wilson, along with penalties. The demand related to the company's Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) contracts for supplying and installing solar power generating systems.

The company had paid GST at 5%, treating the entire solar power generating system as a supply of goods under Serial No. 234 of Schedule I to Notification No. 1/2017.

However, the tax authorities subsequently applied the 70:30 formula, under which 70% of the contract value attracted 5% GST and the remaining 30% attracted 18% GST.

Court Book subscription: bare acts, legal drafts, court judgments and ad-free legal news, plans from ₹30/month

The company challenged the demand before the Bombay High Court, but its writ petition was dismissed on the ground that an alternative statutory remedy was available. It then approached the Supreme Court.

Examining the GST notifications and the recommendations of the GST Council, the Bench noted that the 70:30 valuation mechanism was introduced with effect from January 1, 2019.

The Court observed that Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST dated October 6, 2021, subsequently clarified that taxpayers could also adopt this mechanism for earlier transactions between July 1, 2017, and December 31, 2018. However, the clarification did not make its application compulsory.

The Court observed:

"The fact that the GST Council deemed it appropriate to substitute the existing entry, viz., ‘solar power generator system’ with the entry ‘solar power generator’ indicates that, earlier, the entire SPG system was treated as a unit, which was subjected to central tax @ 2.5%, but after substitution, it is only the solar power generator alone which is treated as a unit and not the entire SPG system. This substitution cannot be applied retrospectively to transactions relating to supply and installation of SPG systems prior to the above notification, when the entire SPG system was treated as a unit for taxation."

The Bench also examined whether the solar power generating systems supplied under EPC contracts qualified as immovable property, making the transactions works contracts under Section 2(119) of the CGST Act.

Referring to earlier Supreme Court decisions, the Court explained that merely fixing equipment to a civil foundation does not automatically make it immovable property.

It noted that the solar panels and modules could be detached from their foundations and used elsewhere. The foundation merely provided stability and supported the proper functioning of the equipment.

The Court held that such transactions did not qualify as works contracts merely because the EPC agreements included certain civil construction activities.

The Supreme Court found that the tax authorities had incorrectly imposed the 70:30 formula on transactions undertaken before January 1, 2019. It also found that invoking the extended limitation period under Section 74 of the CGST Act on allegations of fraud or wilful suppression was unsustainable in the circumstances.

Accordingly, the Bench allowed the appeal and held:

"The appeal is accordingly allowed, setting aside the order dated 17.01.2025 passed by the Joint Commissioner, Central Goods and Services Tax and Central Excise, Thane Commissionerate, and the consequential order dated 24.01.2025 passed by the Superintendent of Central Tax, Range V, Santacruz, Mumbai."

The Court directed that the parties would bear their own costs.

PDF
Download Judgment
Free access
Open PDF

Take CourtBook Everywhere

Access your account on the go with our mobile app.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Join the Court Book WhatsApp channel for latest judgments, notifications, legal news and exam updates