The Allahabad High Court has set aside a Class-A history sheet opened against a man who was acquitted in several criminal cases, ruling that police surveillance cannot be continued arbitrarily or without a reasoned justification. The Court emphasised that maintaining a history sheet must comply with constitutional protections and principles of fair procedure, particularly when the individual has been acquitted of the cases relied upon to justify surveillance.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Siddharth and Justice Vinai Kumar Dwivedi observed that opening history sheets without following a fair procedure may infringe the fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution. The Court also directed the Uttar Pradesh Government to frame safeguards enabling individuals to raise objections before their names are entered in police history sheets.
Background
The petition was filed by Rais Ahmad, who challenged History Sheet Entry No. HS-22A maintained at Chandausi Police Station in Moradabad district.
According to the petitioner, he had been implicated in several criminal cases in 2005 but was subsequently acquitted in those proceedings, including cases under the Indian Penal Code, Arms Act and Uttar Pradesh Gangsters Act.
Despite the acquittals, his name continued to appear in the police history sheet, resulting in repeated visits by police personnel to his residence. He argued that the continued surveillance interfered with his privacy, personal liberty and right to live with dignity.
The State opposed the petition, maintaining that surveillance was necessary because of his criminal antecedents. It also argued that he could approach the Superintendent of Police through a representation.
The Bench examined Regulations 228 to 240 of the U.P. Police Regulations, which govern the opening and maintenance of history sheets. It noted that the provisions originated in the pre-independence period and reflected colonial-era thinking.
The Court observed that the police cannot routinely open history sheets or rely merely on previous criminal proceedings. It also considered the Director General of Police's guidelines dated November 3, 2022, which require a reasonable basis for opening a Class-A history sheet and prohibit using proceedings under the Gangsters Act or Goonda Control Act alone as grounds.
The Bench found that no reasoned order demonstrating the application of mind by the competent police authority had been produced before it.
Emphasising the need for a fair opportunity before imposing surveillance, the Court observed:
"It is high time that this practice should be stopped and before opening of history sheet of Class-A or Class-B against any citizen of the State, he should be given one opportunity to submit his objection before it is accepted by higher official of the police and before such officer directs opening of any Class of history sheet against a citizen. While directing opening of history sheet of Class-A and Class-B, the higher police authority shall record his reasons for directing opening of history sheet of any Class after considering the objection of the citizen filed against the report of the police station."
The Bench further directed the State Government to introduce an annual review mechanism, observing:
"The State Government is directed to look into the procedure of opening of history sheet and make/ issue necessary amendments/guidelines for providing opportunity of objection to the person, against whom, the police submits report recommending the opening of history sheet of Class-A or Class-B before the Senior Police Official. The State Government will also provide for review of the history sheets opened against the citizen, every year, so that, in the cases where implication of persons against whom history sheet was opened and who have been subsequently exonerated/acquitted of the criminal charges, their history sheets are closed and shadow of surveillance by police on their life and liberty gets removed."
Allowing the writ petition, the High Court quashed the history sheet maintained against Rais Ahmad under Entry No. HS-22A.
The Court directed that police surveillance of the petitioner be stopped forthwith. It also directed the Registrar (Compliance) to communicate the order to the Principal Secretary (Home), Uttar Pradesh, within one week.




