The Allahabad High Court has upheld the dismissal of a court employee accused of manipulating the age recorded in a criminal case file to help a convicted prisoner claim the benefit of a government premature-release scheme.
Justice Anish Kumar Gupta dismissed a writ petition filed by Smt. Seema Sharma, holding that interference with judicial records amounts to serious misconduct and does not warrant a lenient approach. The Court also declined to interfere with the factual findings recorded during the departmental inquiry and upheld the punishment of dismissal from service.
Background
The petitioner was initially appointed as a paid apprentice in the Muzaffarnagar judgeship on September 13, 1978. She was later regularised as a Junior Clerk and promoted as Assistant Record Keeper in 1985.
The dispute concerned Sessions Trial No. 98 of 1977, in which an accused named Juber had been convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. His age was recorded as 19 years in his statement under Section 313 CrPC.
In 2000, a government scheme provided for the release of certain life convicts who had completed the prescribed imprisonment period and were above 60 years of age. During this period, a questionnaire issued on September 13, 2000, by the petitioner mentioned Juber's age as 38 years instead of 19 years.
A departmental inquiry followed. The inquiry officer found that the age recorded in the original judicial document had been manipulated and held the petitioner responsible.
Initially, the District Judge imposed a penalty of withholding one increment for two years. However, following an appeal, the Administrative Judge issued a notice proposing enhancement of punishment and subsequently modified it to dismissal from service on October 4, 2010.
The petitioner argued that other employees had also handled the record room during the relevant period and that no handwriting expert had established her responsibility for the alleged manipulation. She also pointed out that she had been on leave during certain periods.
The High Court, however, observed that the relevant period was between July 6 and September 13, 2000, when the petitioner was admittedly in charge of the concerned record. She was not on leave during this period.
The Court also noted that she had received the charge-sheet, participated in the inquiry and cross-examined witnesses.
Emphasising the seriousness of the misconduct, the Court observed:
"this Court find that the said act of manipulation in the age in the judicial record, is a serious misconduct and which do not attract any sympathy because such manipulation in the judicial record is direct interference with the administration of justice and no lenient view could be taken for the said misconduct."
The Court further clarified that judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution does not permit it to function as an appellate authority over factual findings recorded by departmental and appellate authorities.
The Court further noted that the petitioner had been given an opportunity to defend herself and that the disciplinary proceedings had followed the prescribed procedure.
It observed:
"It is settled position of law that this Court while exercising the power of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, cannot interfered with the finding of fact recorded by the inquiry officer, disciplinary authority as well as by the appellate authority and this Court cannot sit in Appeal against the findings recorded by the inquiry officer or the appellate authority."
The High Court found no illegality in the departmental inquiry or the subsequent enhancement of punishment by the appellate authority. It held that the findings against the petitioner were based on the inquiry record and did not warrant interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Accordingly, Justice Anish Kumar Gupta dismissed the writ petition and upheld the dismissal order dated October 4, 2010.
Case Details
Case Title: Smt. Seema Sharma v. High Court of Judicature at Allahabad through Registrar General and Others
Case Number: Writ-A No. 71889 of 2010
Judge: Justice Anish Kumar Gupta
Decision Date: November 2, 2026




