The Allahabad High Court has dismissed a wholesale trader’s petition seeking permission to sell fresh or green coconuts at the Navin Phal Sabzi Mandi Sthal in Sahibabad, Ghaziabad. The Court held that coconut is classified as an oilseed under the Uttar Pradesh Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964, and cannot be traded in a market yard specifically designated for fruits and vegetables.
A Division Bench of Justice Alok Mathur and Justice Amitabh Kumar Rai also rejected the challenge to the State Government's 1995 notification placing coconut under the category of agriculture and oilseeds.
Background
The petition was filed by M/s Three Star Fruit Company through its proprietor Umar Farooque. The firm, which had been trading in fruits and vegetables under a licence issued by the Mandi Samiti since 2003, claimed that it had previously been allowed to bring green coconuts into the Sahibabad market.
The dispute arose after the authorities restricted the entry of coconuts, relying on their classification as oilseeds rather than fruits.
The petitioner argued that green coconut is botanically a fruit and should therefore be included under the horticulture and fruits category. It also challenged the notification dated January 30, 1995, which placed coconut under agriculture and oilseeds.
The State opposed the petition, arguing that the Sahibabad mandi is exclusively meant for fruits and vegetables. It submitted that coconut could instead be traded at the designated cereal mandi in Ghaziabad upon payment of applicable user charges.
Examining the provisions of the 1964 Act and subsequent government notifications, the Bench explained that the permission to trade in non-notified agricultural produce upon payment of user charges does not automatically allow its sale in every market yard. The commodities permitted in a particular market must correspond to its notified category.
The Court noted that coconut was included in the list of specified agricultural produce for the Ghaziabad market area in 1996 but was subsequently excluded through a notification dated July 18, 2003. Its trade in market yards was later permitted under the user-charge arrangement introduced through the order dated September 17, 2021.
However, the Bench clarified that this permission did not extend coconut trading to a fruit and vegetable market yard.
The Court observed:
"The expression “coconut” cannot be interpreted to mean only green or tender coconut; rather, it encompasses several forms, including tender coconut, watery coconut, dried coconut and copra."
The Bench also considered the distinction between botanical classification and ordinary commercial understanding. It observed that different forms of coconut are commercially recognised as one commodity, and the fact that tender coconut may be considered a fruit does not make every form of coconut a fruit.
On the petitioner's claim of previous permission to trade, the Court remarked:
"Mere inaction on the part of the authorities cannot, by itself, create any right in favour of the petitioner-firm to continue trading in green coconut when such trade is otherwise not legally permissible."
The Bench concluded that the petitioner's licence for the fruit and vegetable market did not authorise coconut trading. It also found no constitutional ground to interfere with the classification under the 1995 notification.
Accordingly, the Allahabad High Court dismissed the writ petition and made no order as to costs.
Case Details
Case Title: M/s Three Star Fruit Company Through Proprietor Umar Farooque v. State of U.P. & Others
Case Number: Writ-C No. 4780 of 2025
Judges: Justice Alok Mathur and Justice Amitabh Kumar Rai
Decision Date: November 12, 2026




