Logo

Buyer of Company Land Need Not Prove Board Resolution Was Validly Passed: Supreme Court

CB News Desk
Add Court Book as a preferred source on Google

The Supreme Court ruled that third-party buyers need not prove a company's internal Board proceedings when purchasing property based on a resolution provided by its director. - Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s. J & A Avenues India Private Limited and Others

Buyer of Company Land Need Not Prove Board Resolution Was Validly Passed: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has ruled that a third-party purchaser of company property cannot be held responsible for proving whether the company's internal Board meeting was properly conducted or whether the resolution authorising the sale was validly passed. Applying the Doctrine of Indoor Management, the Court held that a purchaser acting in good faith can rely on a Board resolution produced by a company director.

The Court set aside the orders of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), which had declared the sale of 9 acres and 28 guntas of land invalid.

Background

The dispute arose from the sale of land owned by M/s J & A Avenues India Private Limited to Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. The company was jointly owned by a mother and her son, who each held 50% of its shares and served as directors.

The company had allegedly authorised the sale through a Board resolution dated August 1, 2015. Subsequently, a sale deed was executed on September 4, 2015, transferring 9 acres and 28 guntas of land to Elaine Info Solutions.

Court Book subscription: bare acts, legal drafts, court judgments and ad-free legal news, plans from ₹30/month

The mother later approached the NCLT under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013, alleging that she had neither received notice of the Board meeting nor participated in it. She challenged the resolution and the registered sale deed, claiming that the transaction had taken place without her knowledge or consent.

The NCLT declared the resolution and sale deed null and void. It also directed cancellation of the registered document and restoration of the property in the company's name. The NCLAT upheld the decision, following which Elaine Info Solutions approached the Supreme Court.

A Bench comprising Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva examined whether an unrelated third-party purchaser could be expected to establish the validity of a company's internal Board proceedings.

The Court observed that the purchaser was not involved in the company's internal affairs and could not be expected to know whether the directors had properly convened the meeting.

The judgment stated:

"Appellant, being an unrelated third-party, cannot be made liable for proving the holding of the meeting and passing of a resolution in the said meeting. A third-party purchaser can only act bona fidely when one of the two directors, being a 50% shareholder produces a resolution of the Board of Directors."

The Court further held that the Doctrine of Indoor Management applied to the circumstances. This principle protects outsiders dealing with a company in good faith by allowing them to presume that its internal procedures have been properly followed.

The Bench also considered the company's audited financial statements. It noted that the sale transaction and the amount received had been reflected in the company's accounts, which were signed by both the mother and the son.

The Court observed:

"The Notes to the Financial Statements specifically mentions about the execution of the subject Sale Deed and that the Company had executed a sale deed for sale of 9 Acres 28 Guntas of agriculture land."

The Bench also noted that the mother had signed the financial statements on September 2, 2016, despite subsequently claiming that she was unaware of the transaction.

It further observed that the challenge to the sale deed was brought after three years, even though the transaction had been disclosed in the company's financial records.

On the absence of the company's Income Tax Returns before the forums, the Court also held that an adverse inference had to be drawn against the company.

Allowing Elaine Info Solutions' appeal, the Supreme Court set aside the NCLT order dated August 2, 2019, and the NCLAT order dated March 18, 2020. It dismissed the mother's petition under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013, and dismissed the son's separate appeal as infructuous.

The Court clarified that it had not examined the merits of the pending specific performance suit, which must be decided independently on its own merits.

PDF
Download Judgment
Free access
Open PDF

Take CourtBook Everywhere

Access your account on the go with our mobile app.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Join the Court Book WhatsApp channel for latest judgments, notifications, legal news and exam updates