The Delhi High Court has upheld a Family Court order directing a man to undergo DNA testing to determine whether he is the biological father of a young girl, observing that the child's right to know her parentage outweighs the man's privacy concerns in the circumstances of the case.
The Court dismissed the man's appeal against the DNA testing direction and ordered that the samples be collected confidentially, with the DNA report sent to the Family Court in a sealed cover.
Background
The woman claimed that she married the appellant on June 5, 1997, and lived with him in Delhi and Gujarat. According to her, the man left her in 2009, but they later lived together again in Delhi between November 2009 and July 2010. She claimed that the girl, born on March 10, 2011, was conceived during this period.
The man denied the marriage, relationship and paternity claim. He stated that he knew the woman only as a widow residing in Budh Vihar, Delhi, where he worked as an electrician, and that he was already married to another woman.
Earlier proceedings under the Hindu Marriage Act and Section 125 CrPC were dismissed after the woman failed to establish her marriage with him. However, the High Court clarified that those proceedings concerned the alleged marriage and the woman's maintenance claim, and did not decide the child's biological paternity.
The child subsequently filed a separate suit seeking a DNA test and a declaration regarding her biological father.
The High Court noted that the earlier judgments had not determined the question of paternity and that the child was not a party to those proceedings. It observed that the failure to establish a marriage did not automatically resolve whether the appellant was the child's biological father.
The Court also found that the woman's testimony regarding their alleged cohabitation during the period of conception had not been challenged in cross-examination or rebutted by contrary evidence. The appellant had also not entered the witness box to support his denial.
The Bench relied on Supreme Court judgments governing DNA testing and observed that such a test may be directed when paternity is directly in issue and the available evidence cannot conclusively resolve the controversy.
"The test is not sought to cast a doubt upon the legitimacy of a child, but by the child herself, to know her father."
The Court further observed that an adverse inference from refusal to undergo DNA testing could not replace scientific evidence when the test was necessary to determine the truth.
"Once a strong and eminent need is established, a child's right to know her parentage through the best available evidence cannot be denied by replacing scientific facts with a comparatively weak legal assumption."
On the appellant's privacy objection, the Court held that the right to privacy is not absolute and must be balanced against the child's right to know her biological origin. In the present circumstances, the balance favoured the child's interest.
The Delhi High Court found no infirmity in the Family Court's order directing DNA testing and dismissed the appeal.
The Family Court was directed to fix an early date for the appellant and the child to appear before the Medical Superintendent/Head of Department of Forensic Medicine at BSA Hospital for sample collection. The samples must be collected confidentially, and the DNA report must be forwarded to the Family Court in a sealed cover.
The Court also clarified that the question of paternity and the child's prayer for declaration would be decided by the Family Court after considering the DNA report and the evidence on record.




