Logo

Couple’s Religious Visits and Family Photographs Cannot Disprove Matrimonial Cruelty: Jharkhand High Court

Shivam
Add Court Book as a preferred source on Google

Jharkhand High Court rules that religious visits, family functions and photographs cannot automatically disprove matrimonial cruelty, setting aside a Family Court's dismissal of a divorce petition.

Couple’s Religious Visits and Family Photographs Cannot Disprove Matrimonial Cruelty: Jharkhand High Court

The Jharkhand High Court has observed that occasional visits to religious places, participation in family functions and photographs taken during celebrations cannot automatically disprove allegations of matrimonial cruelty. The Court emphasised that marital relationships must be examined in their entirety rather than judged through a few apparently happy moments.

Background

The matter arose from a wife's appeal against a Family Court judgment dismissing her divorce petition under Sections 13(1)(ia) and 13(1)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, which deal with cruelty and desertion.

The wife had alleged that she faced physical and mental harassment during her marriage, including demands for cash and a vehicle, mistreatment, and repeated threats of divorce. She also claimed that her jewellery had been taken away and that she was ultimately compelled to leave the matrimonial home.

The husband denied these allegations. He argued that the wife had voluntarily left the matrimonial home and relied on photographs, religious visits and family celebrations to dispute her allegations. The Family Court had accepted the husband's defence and dismissed the divorce petition, prompting the wife to approach the High Court.

Court Book subscription: bare acts, legal drafts, court judgments and ad-free legal news, plans from ₹30/month

A Division Bench comprising Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Akhil Kumar examined the evidence presented by both parties, including the testimony of the wife, her mother and her maternal uncle.

The Bench noted that although the couple had visited religious places, attended family functions and participated in celebrations together, these circumstances alone could not establish that cruelty had never occurred during their marriage.

The Court observed:

"A matrimonial relationship may remain outwardly cordial on certain occasions and yet one spouse may be subjected to humiliation, harassment and mental agony during the course of ordinary matrimonial life. Occasional visits to religious places, participation in family functions or photographs taken during celebrations cannot automatically neutralise the effect of other acts of cruelty."

The Bench also pointed out that the husband had relied heavily on the couple's travels but had failed to produce travel tickets or other documentary evidence establishing the details of those visits.

It further observed that the Family Court had given considerable importance to photographs and social gatherings without properly examining the wife's allegations of sustained harassment.

The Court reiterated:

"It is well settled that the existence of some cordial moments in a matrimonial relationship does not necessarily exclude the possibility of cruelty. A marriage is required to be assessed in its entirety, and the Court cannot disregard the suffering of one spouse merely because the parties were seen together on certain occasions."

The High Court also examined the circumstances under which the wife had left the matrimonial home. It noted that she had been living separately since 2020 and that the husband's subsequent willingness to maintain her could not erase the effect of his earlier conduct.

The Bench found that the wife had reasonable grounds for withdrawing from the matrimonial home. It held that the Family Court had failed to properly assess the cumulative effect of the evidence while deciding the divorce petition.

Holding that the wife's evidence established matrimonial cruelty under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the High Court found that the Family Court's decision suffered from an error in appreciating the evidence.

Accordingly, the Division Bench set aside the Family Court's judgment dated April 30, 2026, and decree dated May 7, 2026, passed in Original Suit No. 61 of 2022.

The appeal was allowed.

PDF
Download Judgment
Free access
Open PDF

Take CourtBook Everywhere

Access your account on the go with our mobile app.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Join the Court Book WhatsApp channel for latest judgments, notifications, legal news and exam updates