The Delhi High Court has upheld a Family Court order declaring a marriage void under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, after finding that multiple official identity, educational and employment records supported the husband's case regarding the woman's disputed identity and parentage. The Division Bench of Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar dismissed her appeal, holding that her explanation of errors in childhood school records and the paternity report were insufficient to displace the documentary evidence on record.
Background
The matrimonial dispute arose after the husband questioned the woman's identity, parentage and religious affiliation. He alleged that she had represented herself under a different name and family background before their marriage.
The woman disputed these allegations, maintaining that she was born and brought up in a Hindu family and that the discrepancies in her educational and identity documents resulted from an erroneous entry made by her mother during school admission.
She also relied on a paternity report dated November 24, 2025, and documents from Axis Bank to support her claim of parentage.
The Family Court, however, accepted the husband's application under Order XII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure and declared the marriage void on September 16, 2026. Challenging this decision, the woman approached the High Court.
The High Court examined the Aadhaar card, PAN, CBSE certificates, bank statements and employment records. It noted that these documents consistently carried the same disputed name and parentage, and their genuineness had not been challenged.
The Bench observed:
"The Appellant's explanation that the entries were made erroneously at the time of her school admission does not, by itself, displace the evidentiary value of the subsequent records. The documents relied upon are not confined to school records originating during her childhood. The Aadhaar Card continued to be held and used in the name “Yasmeen”, while her bank account and employment records also reflected the same name. Significantly, the employment documents and bank statements show that she continued to transact and receive her salary under the said name even around the period of the marriage, during the year 2024."
The Court also considered the paternity report relied upon by the woman. It noted that the report was neither obtained under a court's direction nor based on samples collected under judicial supervision.
The Bench further observed:
"The report was not obtained pursuant to any direction of a competent court, nor were the samples collected under judicial supervision. In the circumstances, the report, standing by itself, cannot be treated as conclusive proof of paternity so as to displace the consistent documentary record placed before the Family Court."
The Court also referred to Sections 2 and 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act, observing that the statutory conditions governing a Hindu marriage had to be fulfilled.
Finding no legal infirmity in the Family Court's decision, the High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the September 16, 2026 order declaring the marriage void, along with the consequential decree.
Pending applications were also disposed of.




