The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has partly modified a Single Judge's judgment concerning unpaid boarding, lodging and catering charges claimed by Hotel New Metro, Srinagar, after its rooms were hired by the authorities to accommodate protected persons.
The Division Bench held that the hotel was entitled to rental charges for all 19 rooms hired by the Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar, irrespective of whether the rooms were actually occupied. However, catering charges would be payable only for the persons who actually availed food services.
Background
Hotel New Metro, located in Bishember Nagar, Srinagar, was initially hired by the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, in November 2020 to accommodate Sarpanches, Panches, PRI members, municipal councillors and other protected persons. The hotel was later de-hired in October 2021, and certain payments for that period remained pending.
Subsequently, the Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar, hired 19 rooms of the hotel through an order dated October 27, 2021. The rooms remained under the authorities' arrangement until October 25, 2022. After the hotel was vacated, its proprietor submitted bills for boarding, lodging and catering charges.
The authorities, however, constituted a committee to verify the bills based on the actual occupancy of the rooms. The committee recommended payment only for rooms that had actually been occupied. Aggrieved by the reduction in payment, the hotel approached the High Court.
A Single Judge had allowed the petition and directed the authorities to clear the hotel's claims for the period from November 15, 2020, to October 25, 2022. The Union Territory challenged that decision before the Division Bench.
The Division Bench first examined the claim relating to the earlier hiring period from November 15, 2020, to October 5, 2021. It observed that the hotel had not specifically sought payment for this period in its original writ petition, nor had the Divisional Commissioner, who was the concerned authority, been made a party to the proceedings.
The Court held that the Single Judge could not have granted relief concerning this period without giving the competent authority an opportunity to contest the claim.
"The direction of the writ Court, insofar as it pertains to liquidation of the liability of the respondent for the aforesaid period is concerned, is certainly beyond the scope of the writ petition and is otherwise in breach of the principles of natural justice."
On the claim for the 19 rooms hired from October 27, 2021, to October 25, 2022, the Bench noted that the hiring order did not contain any condition stating that rental charges would be paid only on the basis of actual occupancy.
The Court observed that the hotel was required to keep all 19 rooms available for the protected persons and could not independently rent out rooms that remained unoccupied.
"In the absence of any such clear stipulation in the hiring order dated 27th October, 2021, passed by the Deputy Commissioner, Srinagar, the respondent was under an obligation to keep all the 19 rooms un-booked and ready for accommodating all the 38 protected persons named in the order itself."
The Bench, however, distinguished room rental from catering charges. Since catering charges were fixed on a per-person, per-day basis, the hotel could claim payment only for those who actually availed food services.
The Division Bench partly allowed the appeal and modified the Single Judge's judgment. It set aside the direction to pay boarding and lodging charges for the period from November 15, 2020, to October 5, 2021, while granting the hotel liberty to approach the Divisional Commissioner, Kashmir, through a representation for any outstanding amount relating to that period.
For the subsequent period from October 27, 2021, to October 25, 2022, the Court held that the hotel was entitled to rental charges for all 19 rooms hired, regardless of actual occupancy. Catering charges, however, would be calculated according to the actual number of persons who availed the food services.
The authorities were directed to examine the hotel's claims and release the balance payment within two months. In case of delay, the amount would carry interest at 6% per annum from the date it became due until actual payment.
Case Details
Case Title: Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir & Others v. Hotel New Metro
Case Number: LPA No. 137/2026
Judges: Justice Sanjeev Kumar and Justice Mohd Yousuf Wani
Decision Date: November 17, 2026




