Logo

Karnataka HC Quashes Case Against Man for Reposting News Claiming Siddaramaiah Would Distribute Nation’s Wealth to Muslims

CB News Desk
Add Court Book as a preferred source on Google

The Karnataka High Court quashed an FIR against Vinith Narayan Naik over a social media post claiming Siddaramaiah would distribute the nation's wealth to Muslims. - Vinith Narayan Naik v. State of Karnataka & Another

Karnataka HC Quashes Case Against Man for Reposting News Claiming Siddaramaiah Would Distribute Nation’s Wealth to Muslims

The Karnataka High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against a man booked for allegedly promoting communal hatred through a social media post questioning the Congress manifesto and referring to a televised statement attributed to Chief Minister Siddaramaiah.

The Court held that the allegations did not satisfy the essential requirements of Section 153A of the Indian Penal Code, as the post did not specifically promote hatred or enmity between two distinct communities.

Background

The case arose from a complaint filed on April 29, 2024, by J. Saravanan, a Congress party worker from Bengaluru. He alleged that certain posts had been circulating on X (formerly Twitter) since April 22, 2024, through an account named 'BhikuMhatre (Modi's Family) @MumbaichaDon'.

One of the posts contained a photograph of Siddaramaiah, accompanied by a TV9 news headline stating, "I will share the wealth of the nation to Muslims: CM Siddaramaiah".

Court Book subscription: bare acts, legal drafts, court judgments and ad-free legal news, plans from ₹30/month

The post also carried a comment referring to the Congress manifesto and its alleged reference to Muslims in connection with wealth distribution. The complainant claimed that the publication was intended to create hostility between Hindu and Muslim communities, disturb public peace and damage the Congress Party's reputation.

Following the complaint, Bengaluru Cyber Crime Police registered an FIR against Vinith Narayan Naik under Section 153A IPC and Section 66(C) of the Information Technology Act, 2000.

Naik subsequently approached the High Court seeking to quash the FIR and all consequential proceedings.

Senior Advocate Aruna Shyam, appearing for Naik, argued that his client had merely reposted a news item circulated by TV9. There was no specific attempt to insult any community or provoke hatred or violence.

The petitioner's counsel also pointed out that the police had not investigated the authenticity of the television news report before registering the case. The complaint was also alleged to have been filed with a political motive.

Opposing the petition, Special Public Prosecutor B.N. Jagadeesha argued that the post was intended to create communal hatred by suggesting that wealth belonging to Hindus would be taken away and distributed exclusively to Muslims. The State maintained that the investigation was still at an early stage.

Justice Rajesh Rai K examined the contents of the social media post and the legal requirements of Section 153A IPC. The Court noted that the news item had been broadcast by TV9, but no investigation had been conducted to establish whether the headline accurately represented the Chief Minister's statement.

Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Bilal Ahmed Kaloo v. State of Andhra Pradesh, the High Court reiterated that promoting enmity under Section 153A requires involvement of at least two distinct groups or communities.

The Court observed:

"Merely inciting the feeling of one community or group without any reference to any other community or group cannot attract."

It further noted that the petitioner's accompanying write-up did not specifically refer to two distinct communities or contain material indicating a likelihood of disturbing public tranquillity.

The Court also referred to the constitutional protection available to lawful dissent under Article 19(1)(a), subject to reasonable restrictions.

Observing that the complainant had not appeared despite receiving notice, the Court also considered the allegation that the criminal complaint had been initiated out of political vengeance.

The Court emphasised:

"The right to express dissent in a lawful manner must also be treated as an integral part of the right to lead a dignified and meaningful life guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India."

Justice Rajesh Rai K held that even if the allegations in the complaint and FIR were accepted in their entirety, they did not disclose the essential ingredients of Section 153A IPC.

The Court concluded that continuing the criminal proceedings would amount to an abuse of the process of law.

Accordingly, the Karnataka High Court allowed Vinith Narayan Naik's petition and quashed the FIR registered in Crime No. 17/2024, along with all further proceedings pending before the 45th Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Bengaluru, under Section 153A IPC and Section 66(C) of the Information Technology Act, 2000.

PDF
Download Judgment
Free access
Open PDF

Take CourtBook Everywhere

Access your account on the go with our mobile app.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Join the Court Book WhatsApp channel for latest judgments, notifications, legal news and exam updates