The Karnataka High Court has refused to quash an FIR against a woman accused of allegedly threatening a person and publishing defamatory and intimidating messages about him on Instagram. The Court observed that the constitutional right to freedom of speech does not give anyone unrestricted permission to post anything on social media.
Justice Suraj Govindaraj dismissed the woman's criminal petition and directed the police to complete the investigation at the earliest.
Background
The complaint was filed on April 24, 2025, following which Belthangady Police registered FIR No. 27/2025 under Sections 353(2) and 62 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023.
According to the complaint, the woman allegedly attempted to run over the complainant with an autorickshaw on April 16, 2024. It was further alleged that she had acted at someone else's behest after receiving money to kill him. The complaint also referred to several social media posts allegedly targeting the complainant.
The woman approached the High Court seeking to quash the FIR, arguing that the alleged incident had not occurred and that the autorickshaw driver had not been made an accused in the present case.
The State informed the Court that a separate FIR had been registered against the autorickshaw driver and a charge sheet had been filed in that matter. It also pointed to an Instagram post containing a photograph of the complainant lying in a hospital bed, accompanied by an allegedly inappropriate message, along with other posts said to contain threats.
Rejecting the argument that social media activity could be unrestricted, the Court observed:
"A social media handle being available would not give a free license to any person to post any message that a person wants. The messages which are posted ought to be within the exercise and limits of Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution."
The Court further noted that the photograph of the complainant in a hospital bed, along with the accompanying message, indicated at this stage that the allegations could not be treated as false. However, it made clear that their actual truth and extent would have to be established through investigation.
Justice Govindaraj observed that the earlier interim order had prevented the investigation from progressing. Considering the seriousness of the allegations and the material placed before it, the Court found that the matter required a proper police investigation rather than termination of the proceedings at this stage.
The Court observed:
"It is on account of the interim order which had been passed earlier that the investigation could not go through. Being of the considered opinion that the allegations made are serious enough requiring investigation, this Court passes the following:"
The High Court dismissed the criminal petition and directed the Karnataka Police to conduct the necessary investigation at the earliest and submit its report.
The Court did not determine the truth of the allegations, leaving that question to the investigating agency.
Case Details
Case Title: Shubha v. State of Karnataka & Another
Case Number: Criminal Petition No. 7143 of 2025
Judge: Justice Suraj Govindaraj
Decision Date: October 15, 2026




