The Delhi High Court has held that marrying an Indian citizen does not automatically give a foreign national an enforceable right to obtain an Entry (X-1) or Spouse Visa. Justice Amit Mahajan dismissed a petition filed by a US citizen seeking conversion of her existing e-Tourist Visa into a Spouse Visa, observing that immigration authorities are entitled to examine the circumstances surrounding a marriage before deciding a visa application.
The Court clarified that its decision was limited to the petitioner's claim for immigration benefits and did not determine whether her marriage was genuine or otherwise.
Background
The petitioner, Lisa Hall Srivastava, approached the Delhi High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, seeking conversion of her e-Tourist Visa into an Entry (X-1) Visa following her marriage to Indian citizen Mohd. Wasim Akram.
The couple married according to Muslim rites and customs on December 7, 2025. Their marriage was subsequently registered under the Special Marriage Act, 1954, on March 18, 2026. She submitted an application to the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) on March 27, 2026, seeking the visa conversion.
The petitioner alleged that despite submitting the required documents, her application was not favourably processed and that she and her husband faced repeated enquiries, including questions concerning their age difference.
The Union Government opposed the petition, explaining that the application had been examined in light of the petitioner's previous immigration history and matrimonial relationships.
According to the authorities, her earlier marriages had also formed the basis of applications for immigration benefits. They further referred to her prolonged stay in India, residential arrangements, financial circumstances and explanations regarding her source of income.
The authorities stated that these circumstances raised concerns about whether the present marriage was primarily intended to obtain immigration benefits.
Justice Amit Mahajan examined the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, and relied on the Supreme Court's ruling in Louis De Raedt v. Union of India (1991). The judgment recognised that foreign nationals enjoy protection of life and personal liberty under Article 21, but do not have a fundamental right to reside or settle in India.
The Court observed:
"The mere fact that the Petitioner has entered into a marriage with an Indian citizen does not, by itself, confer an automatic or indefeasible right to conversion of her existing visa into an Entry (X-1) Visa."
The Bench also noted that the marriage certificate issued under the Special Marriage Act could not prevent immigration authorities from examining the surrounding circumstances. It further pointed out that the petitioner's husband had not filed an affidavit supporting her claims about their relationship and cohabitation. However, the Court clarified that this absence alone could not determine whether the marriage was genuine.
Importantly, the Court made it clear that it was not deciding the validity or genuineness of the marriage.
"The observations made herein are confined to the Petitioner's claim for immigration benefits and the action of the Respondents in examining her application. If any representation is pending consideration or is filed in future, the same be decided by the Respondents, in accordance with law."
Finding the government's explanation satisfactory, the Court held that it could not substitute its own assessment for that of the competent immigration authority in matters concerning the admission of foreign nationals.
Accordingly, Justice Amit Mahajan dismissed the writ petition along with the pending applications.




