The Chhattisgarh High Court has dismissed a father's appeal seeking custody of his minor son, observing that a mother's professional commitments and travel for work, by themselves, do not establish that she is unable to take care of the child.
The Division Bench also considered the child's own preference, noting that the approximately 14-year-old boy expressed unwillingness to live with his father during the Court's interaction.
Background
The dispute arose after the couple's marriage was dissolved through a divorce decree dated April 29, 2023. Under a settlement reached before the Lok Adalat on May 13, 2023, the father agreed to pay ₹15,000 per month towards the child's maintenance and was granted visitation rights every Sunday.
The father later approached the Family Court seeking guardianship and custody of his son under Sections 7 and 10 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890. He alleged that the mother, who works as a government doctor, had left the child with his maternal grandparents while travelling for her professional duties. He also raised concerns about the child's education and claimed that his academic performance had suffered.
The mother opposed the plea, stating that the arrangement was made to ensure the child's proper upbringing while she performed her official duties. She maintained that the child was receiving adequate care, education and support in the family environment.
The Family Court rejected the father's custody application in August 2025, prompting him to approach the High Court.
The High Court reiterated that the welfare and best interests of a child remain the primary consideration in custody and guardianship disputes, rather than the legal or preferential rights of either parent.
The Bench observed that the mother's government employment and requirement to travel for official work could not, by themselves, establish that she was incapable of taking care of the child.
"However, the said circumstance, by itself, cannot be considered sufficient to conclude that the respondent/defendant mother is unable to look after the minor."
The Court also noted that the father himself was a doctor and was engaged in professional practice at both Korba and Raipur. Therefore, professional commitments and the consequent lack of time were not circumstances limited to the mother.
The Bench further observed that the father had not produced sufficient documentary evidence to establish that the child's academic performance had deteriorated or that his education was being neglected. It held that merely referring to the grade secured by the child in a particular academic year was insufficient to justify changing the existing custody arrangement.
During the hearing, the Court also interacted with the minor, who was approximately 14 years old. The child expressed unwillingness to reside with his father. While the Court clarified that the child's preference could not be the sole determining factor, it held that the preference deserved consideration along with the other circumstances.
"In such circumstances, abruptly changing his custody merely on the appellant/plaintiff father's apprehension, unsupported by any cogent material, that the minor is not being properly looked after, may adversely affect the minor's mental and emotional well-being."
The Bench found no material establishing that the mother's care was adversely affecting the child's physical, educational or emotional welfare.
The Chhattisgarh High Court dismissed the father's appeal and upheld the Family Court's order refusing to transfer custody of the minor to him.
However, the Court permitted the father to meet and spend time with the child on special occasions, including birthdays, festivals and long vacations, subject to the child's prior willingness, mutual convenience of the parties, and the child's educational schedule and comfort.
Case Details
Case Title: Dr. Santosh Bhardwaj v. Smt. Bhorlaxmi Bhardwaj
Case Number: FA(MAT) No. 346 of 2025
Judges: Justice Parth Prateem Sahu and Justice Sushma Sawant
Decision Date: November 17, 2026




