Logo

Only Mother Entitled to Dependency Compensation for Unmarried Son's Death; Father and Sisters Not Dependents: Himachal Pradesh High Court

Ravin Yadav
Add Court Book as a preferred source on Google

The Himachal Pradesh High Court reduced motor accident compensation and held that only the mother was entitled to dependency compensation for the death of her unmarried son. - Om Parkash and Another v. Anita and Others

Only Mother Entitled to Dependency Compensation for Unmarried Son's Death; Father and Sisters Not Dependents: Himachal Pradesh High Court

The Himachal Pradesh High Court has held that where an unmarried man dies in a motor accident, his mother alone can be treated as a dependent for calculating compensation in the absence of evidence showing that his father or siblings were financially dependent upon him.

The Court modified the compensation awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, holding that the deceased's father and sisters could not be considered dependents merely because they were his family members. The compensation was consequently recalculated, with the mother receiving the entire amount.

Background

The case arose from a road accident on November 25, 2020, near Village Khodri in Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur. Mohit, who was riding a motorcycle, suffered fatal injuries after a car allegedly hit the motorcycle from behind.

His family approached the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Paonta Sahib, seeking compensation of ₹25 lakh. They claimed that Mohit was working as a Munshi and earning ₹15,000 per month. His parents and two sisters also claimed to be financially dependent on him.

Court Book subscription: bare acts, legal drafts, court judgments and ad-free legal news, plans from ₹30/month

The Tribunal awarded ₹17,20,400 in compensation, along with costs and interest at 7.5% per annum. The vehicle owner and another appellant challenged the award before the High Court, questioning both the assessment of income and the inclusion of the father and sisters as dependents.

The High Court first examined the deceased's income. It noted that the claimants had not produced documentary evidence to establish his alleged monthly salary of ₹15,000. The Court therefore upheld the Tribunal's assessment of his notional income at ₹8,250 per month.

On the question of dependency, the Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, which lays down the general principle applicable to compensation claims involving unmarried deceased persons.

The Court observed:

"Petitioner No.2, being the father and petitioners No.3 & 4, being the sisters of the deceased, cannot be considered as his dependents and only petitioner No.1 alone being his mother, will be considered as dependent on the earnings of the deceased."

The Court explained that, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, the father is ordinarily presumed to have his own income, while siblings may be earning independently, married or dependent on their father.

It further held that 40% of the deceased's income would be added towards future prospects, while 50% would be deducted towards his personal and living expenses. The multiplier of 16 was also retained.

The High Court recalculated the loss of dependency at ₹11,08,800. It additionally awarded ₹15,000 towards funeral expenses, ₹15,000 towards loss of estate and ₹40,000 towards filial consortium payable to the mother.

The total compensation was consequently reduced from ₹17,20,400 to ₹11,78,800.

The Court held that the deceased's mother alone was entitled to receive the revised compensation. The remaining terms of the Tribunal's award, including the interest component, were left unchanged.

The appeal was disposed of accordingly.

Take CourtBook Everywhere

Access your account on the go with our mobile app.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Join the Court Book WhatsApp channel for latest judgments, notifications, legal news and exam updates