Logo

Rajasthan High Court Upholds Two Court Appearance Or Vakalatnama Requirement For Bar Association Voters

Shivam
Add Court Book as a preferred source on Google

The Rajasthan High Court restored voter eligibility conditions for RHCBA elections, ruling that advocates must prove active court practice through vakalatnamas or appearance records to vote. - Virendra Agrawal v. Election Committee, Rajasthan High Court Bar Association & Others

Rajasthan High Court Upholds Two Court Appearance Or Vakalatnama Requirement For Bar Association Voters

The Rajasthan High Court has restored two eligibility conditions for voters in the upcoming annual elections of the Rajasthan High Court Bar Association (RHCBA), Jaipur. The court held that an Election Committee is fully within its authority to require that voters demonstrate active professional practice - and that doing so is not the same as amending the association's bye-laws.

Background

The matter came before the court after a senior member of RHCBA, Virendra Agrawal, filed a writ petition raising concerns about election reforms and the need to uphold standards within the Bar. At the core of the dispute were two notices issued by the Election Committee on November 3 and 4, 2026. These notices required that only those members who could produce order sheets showing at least two court appearances at the Jaipur Bench, or copies of two vakalatnamas (legal authority documents filed by advocates), would be eligible to vote in the elections.

Shortly after, an anonymous resolution - reportedly from the General House of RHCBA - attempted to nullify the conditions. The Election Committee, apparently misled by this resolution, withdrew the conditions through a subsequent notice dated November 17, 2026. It is this withdrawal that the petitioner challenged before the High Court.

Justice Anand Sharma, hearing the matter, was clear that the Election Committee had acted with legitimate intent. The court noted that the conditions were introduced with a bona fide purpose - to ensure that those voting in bar elections are genuinely engaged in legal practice before the court, not merely nominal members.

Court Book subscription: bare acts, legal drafts, court judgments and ad-free legal news, plans from ₹30/month

The court drew an important distinction between membership of a Bar Association and the right to vote in its elections. While membership may continue regardless of court activity, the right to participate in elections, the court said, can be regulated by reasonable conditions connected to actual professional work.

"The eligibility conditions prescribed under the Bye-laws are required to be construed as laying down the minimum requirements for participation in the electoral process. Unless the Bye-laws expressly prohibit the prescription of additional reasonable regulatory requirements, the Election Committee cannot be rendered powerless to adopt appropriate measures for ensuring that the voters' list comprises members who are genuinely engaged in active practice. The authority to conduct elections necessarily carries with it the incidental power to prescribe reasonable modalities for verification of the eligibility of voters, provided such measures are not inconsistent with the Bye-laws or otherwise arbitrary."

The court also made it clear that the conditions did not amount to an overriding of the existing bye-laws. Rather, they were a reasonable additional standard - one that any member could meet by producing basic documentary proof.

"The condition is neither onerous nor excessive. It provides two alternative modes of establishing professional engagement and is founded upon objective and verifiable documentary material. The requirement is not intended to assess the professional competence or standing of an advocate but merely to ascertain whether the member has remained professionally connected with the Court during the relevant period."

The court also referenced the Supreme Court's ruling in Supreme Court Bar Association & Ors. v. B.D. Kaushik (2011), which had recognised that electoral participation in a court-attached bar association can legitimately be linked to active professional engagement.

The High Court quashed the November 17 notice that had withdrawn the voter eligibility conditions and restored the original notices of November 3 and 4. It directed the Election Committee to revise its schedule to allow members to file fresh affidavits along with proof of appearances or vakalatnamas up to 5:00 PM on November 23, 2026, with the submission window also open on Sunday, November 22. A fresh list of eligible members is to be published on November 24, 2026.

The writ petition filed by Virendra Agrawal was accordingly allowed.

PDF
Download Judgment
Free access
Open PDF

Take CourtBook Everywhere

Access your account on the go with our mobile app.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Join the Court Book WhatsApp channel for latest judgments, notifications, legal news and exam updates