Logo

Supreme Court Reinstates CISF Constable Removed After Seeking Leave to Care for Wife Following Miscarriage, Grants 50% Back Wages

CB News Desk
Add Court Book as a preferred source on Google

The Supreme Court quashed a CISF constable's removal over a leave dispute involving his wife's medical condition and ordered reinstatement with 50% back wages. - Sumit Kumar v. Union of India & Ors.

Supreme Court Reinstates CISF Constable Removed After Seeking Leave to Care for Wife Following Miscarriage, Grants 50% Back Wages

The Supreme Court of India has set aside the removal of a Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) constable who was dismissed from service following a dispute over leave sought to care for his wife after she suffered a miscarriage and underwent major surgery. The Court held that the departmental findings were unsustainable and that removal from service was excessively harsh in the circumstances.

A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh allowed the appeals filed by Sumit Kumar, quashed the disciplinary proceedings resulting in his removal, and directed his reinstatement with consequential benefits and 50% back wages.

Background

Sumit Kumar joined the CISF as a Constable (General Duty) in 2012. In October 2017, he took leave because of serious medical complications suffered by his wife during pregnancy. Following a miscarriage and subsequent surgeries, he sought further leave to look after her.

Although his leave was initially extended, his subsequent request for twelve additional days led to a dispute with the departmental authorities. On December 6, 2017, he submitted a resignation through the grievance portal, claiming that he was under considerable mental stress.

Court Book subscription: bare acts, legal drafts, court judgments and ad-free legal news, plans from ₹30/month

The CISF subsequently initiated disciplinary proceedings against him on three charges, including alleged disobedience, intimidation through relatives and reference to five previous minor penalties. On May 1, 2018, he was removed from service. The Delhi High Court upheld the decision, prompting him to approach the Supreme Court.

Examining the first charge, the Supreme Court found that the department had not produced reliable material establishing that Kumar had deliberately disobeyed a specific direction to appear before the Commandant.

The Court observed:

The absence of a written direction or telephone record may not, by itself, be conclusive, however, in the absence of other reliable evidence establishing that the direction was in fact communicated to the Appellant, the charge of deliberate disobedience cannot be sustained merely on the basis of the allegation. Further, the circumstances in which the Appellant submitted his resignation, particularly the serious medical condition of his wife and his request for further leave, were relevant considerations which required due examination before attributing to him an intention to pressurise the administration.

Regarding the second charge, the Bench found no satisfactory evidence connecting Kumar with the circulation of his wife's video or the alleged threats made by his relatives. It clarified that an employee cannot be held responsible merely because of his relationship with persons accused of such conduct.

The Court also held that previously punished misconduct could not be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct or used to fill gaps in proving the current charges.

The Bench further identified procedural irregularities in the departmental inquiry. Hindi translations of documents were supplied only after prosecution witnesses had been examined. His request for a defence assistant was also rejected, affecting his opportunity to prepare an effective defence.

The Court observed:

The supply of translated copies at such a belated stage deprived the Appellant of an effective opportunity to understand the material relied upon against him and to prepare his defence.

On the question of punishment, the Supreme Court held that removal from service was manifestly excessive and disproportionate to the misconduct, if any, established against Kumar.

The Bench relied on the principle laid down in Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India, emphasising that punishment must suit both the misconduct and the individual and should not be unduly harsh.

The Court ultimately allowed the appeals and set aside the Delhi High Court's judgment dated February 14, 2024, along with its review order dated July 12, 2024. It also quashed the removal order dated May 1, 2018, and the subsequent appellate and revisional orders.

Considering the passage of time, the Court declined to send the matter back for a fresh departmental inquiry. It directed the CISF to reinstate Sumit Kumar forthwith, grant him all consequential benefits and pay 50% of the back wages for the period between his removal and reinstatement.

PDF
Download Judgment
Free access
Open PDF

Take CourtBook Everywhere

Access your account on the go with our mobile app.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Join the Court Book WhatsApp channel for latest judgments, notifications, legal news and exam updates