The Supreme Court has dismissed the Karnataka government's appeal challenging the Karnataka High Court's decision permitting bike taxi services to operate in the State, allowing the services to continue under the regulatory framework laid down by the High Court.
A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice N Kotiswar Singh passed the order while rejecting the State's challenge to the High Court's January 23 judgment. The dispute concerned whether motorcycles could be registered as transport vehicles and used as contract carriages for carrying passengers through app-based aggregators.
Background
The Karnataka High Court's Division Bench had earlier set aside a single-judge order that directed bike taxi services to stop operating until the State Government framed the necessary policy and guidelines.
The Division Bench allowed appeals filed by aggregators including Ola, Uber and Rapido, along with motorcycle owners and the Bike Taxi Welfare Association. It held that motorcycles could be registered as transport vehicles and used as contract carriages, subject to regulatory conditions imposed by the authorities.
The Karnataka Government challenged this decision before the Supreme Court, raising concerns regarding passenger safety, insurance coverage, traffic congestion and the absence of adequate safeguards for bike taxi operations. Auto and taxi driver associations also opposed the High Court's decision, arguing that bike taxis would affect existing transport operators.
During the hearing, the Supreme Court highlighted the affordability of bike taxi services and questioned the State's concerns about their operation. Justice Sharma also referred to a conversation with young women working in his office who regularly used bike taxis to commute.
"I asked them, how do you come to my office? They said on a motorbike because they do not have the money to hire a cab. I asked them, why don't you take an auto? They said, 'Sir, it is five times the fare'."
The Court also observed that bike taxi services could be regulated rather than prohibited, particularly considering their availability and use in several States.
After considering the submissions, the Supreme Court dismissed the Karnataka government's appeal. The dismissal leaves the Karnataka High Court's judgment intact, allowing bike taxi services to continue operating in the State, subject to applicable regulatory requirements.
"While concerned authorities are not precluded from examining the relevant aspects, the same will not be denied on the ground that motorcycles cannot be operated as transport vehicles or contract carriages."
The High Court had directed the authorities to consider applications for registering motorcycles as transport vehicles and granting permits to operate them as contract carriages.
It had also permitted aggregators to submit fresh applications for consideration in accordance with law.




