The Supreme Court has restored a compensation decree of ₹8.70 lakh in favour of a woman who lost her right hand after suffering electric shock from a live transmission wire, holding that a court cannot reject a claimant's case merely because the incident appears suspicious.
A Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar set aside the Rajasthan High Court's judgment, observing that civil disputes must be decided on the evidence presented by the parties rather than assumptions or doubts about the occurrence.
Background
The case arose from an incident dated July 15, 2011, when Rekha, who was a minor at the time, allegedly suffered severe burn injuries after coming into contact with a live electric wire in village Harivansh Ka Pura-Pathaur Ka Pura.
According to her case, the electricity transmission wires maintained by Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited (JVVNL) had become loose and were hanging dangerously close to the ground. She was initially taken to a local health centre and subsequently shifted to Agra for further treatment, where her right hand had to be amputated.
The trial court awarded her ₹8,70,000 in compensation with 6% annual interest. However, the Rajasthan High Court overturned the decree on May 10, 2024, questioning the credibility of the incident, the delay in reporting it to the police and the absence of medical expert evidence.
Disagreeing with the High Court, the Supreme Court observed that the trial court had assessed the evidence after a full-fledged trial. The electricity company's witness had also admitted that maintaining transmission lines was the respondents' responsibility, while acknowledging that he was neither present during the incident nor on duty that day.
The Bench emphasised that an appellate court should not interfere with factual findings merely because it has developed doubts about the claimant's version.
The Court observed:
"A civil suit should be decided on the basis of evidence produced by the parties and not by merely raising a doubt on the claim made by the plaintiff."
The Bench further explained that civil cases are decided on the principle of preponderance of probabilities, meaning that the court must determine whether a fact is more likely to be true based on the available evidence. Proof beyond reasonable doubt is not required in civil proceedings.
It also clarified that minor inconsistencies or delays in reporting an incident cannot automatically undermine an otherwise supported claim.
The Court further held:
"The appellate Court can interfere with the judgment of the Court of first instance if it suffers from material irregularity, or is based on inadmissible evidence or a misreading of the evidence. But the appellate Court is not entitled to interfere with a judgment merely on the ground of suspicion without weighing truthfulness of the witnesses."
Finding that the High Court had committed a serious error in interfering with the trial court's findings on mere suspicion, the Supreme Court held that the case attracted the principle of strict liability against the electricity authorities.
Accordingly, the Bench set aside the Rajasthan High Court's order dated May 10, 2024, restored the trial court's judgment directing payment of ₹8,70,000 with 6% interest until payment, and allowed Rekha's appeal.
Pending applications were also disposed of.




