The Supreme Court has dismissed appeals filed by Twinstar Technologies Limited against the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal’s (NCLAT) decision to set aside the resolution plan for Videocon Industries Limited and remit it to the Committee of Creditors (CoC) for reconsideration. The Court held that the plan did not adequately protect the statutory payment rights of financial creditors who had voted against it.
A Bench comprising Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe also dismissed connected appeals concerning the exclusion of Videocon Group’s overseas oil and gas assets in Brazil and Indonesia from the insolvency proceedings of Videocon Industries Limited.
Background
The dispute arose from the insolvency proceedings involving Videocon Industries Limited and 12 other group companies. In 2020, Twinstar Technologies Limited submitted a resolution plan involving a financial outlay of approximately Rs. 2,962.02 crore. The CoC approved the proposal with 95.09% voting support.
However, Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI Limited and SIDBI opposed the plan, questioning the proposed payment mechanism. It provided for a combination of upfront payments and non-convertible debentures worth Rs. 2,700 crore, redeemable over six years.
The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) approved the plan in June 2021 but directed that dissenting financial creditors receive their liquidation value in cash before payments were made to other financial creditors. The lenders challenged the approval, following which the NCLAT set aside the plan and sent it back to the CoC.
Examining the payment arrangement, the Supreme Court referred to its earlier decision in Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association v. NBCC (India) Ltd. The Bench clarified that the statutory entitlement of dissenting financial creditors under Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code must be satisfied through payment in money.
The Court found that redeemable debentures payable over six years could not fulfil this requirement. It further held that the plan did not adequately secure the priority required for dissenting financial creditors under Regulation 38(1)(b) of the CIRP Regulations.
The Bench emphasised that statutory compliance must be reflected in the resolution plan itself and cannot be left to a future assurance or undertaking. It also clarified that the NCLT could not independently rewrite the payment structure of an approved plan; any reconsideration of the proposal had to be undertaken by the CoC.
Rejecting Twinstar’s argument that the CoC had become functus officio after approving the plan, the Court explained that the committee does not lose its existence or all authority merely because it has voted on a resolution plan.
The Court stated,
“The CoC does not cease to exist upon approving a plan.”
It further recognised the NCLAT’s power to remit a legally defective plan to the CoC, while emphasising that such intervention must rest on established grounds of statutory non-compliance and respect the timelines prescribed under the insolvency framework.
In the connected appeals, former Videocon promoter Venugopal Dhoot challenged the exclusion of overseas oil and gas assets in Brazil and Indonesia from Videocon Industries’ insolvency proceedings.
The Supreme Court rejected this contention, holding that a holding company and its subsidiaries are separate legal entities. Merely because a company holds shares in a subsidiary, the subsidiary’s assets do not automatically become assets of the holding company for insolvency purposes.
The Bench observed,
“The holding company does not own the assets of its subsidiary.”
The Court also took note of the promoter’s earlier positions concerning the treatment of these foreign assets while examining his challenge.
The Supreme Court dismissed Twinstar Technologies Limited’s appeals and upheld the NCLAT’s decision to set aside the resolution plan and remit the matter to the Committee of Creditors for reconsideration.
It also dismissed the connected appeals filed by Venugopal Dhoot and the VIL Vendors Association, while allowing the association to pursue remedies available to it under law.
.webp&w=2048&q=75)



