The Patna High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against a tractor driver accused in a case involving the alleged transportation of Public Distribution System (PDS) grains, holding that the material collected during investigation did not establish the essential ingredients of the offences alleged against him.
The Court observed that merely being a driver of the vehicle allegedly used for transporting the grains was not sufficient to establish criminal liability for offences involving misappropriation, cheating or conspiracy.
Background
The case arose from Sheikhpura (Hathiyawan O.P.) Police Station Case No. 161 of 2013, registered on the basis of a written report submitted by the Block Supply Officer, Sheikhpura. The prosecution alleged the lifting of PDS grains and their transportation to Jaishri Krishan Rice Mill.
The case was registered under Sections 420, 409 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, along with Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act. The petitioner had sought discharge before the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Sheikhpura, but the application was rejected on July 29, 2016.
He subsequently approached the High Court seeking quashing of the order. His counsel argued that he was neither named in the FIR nor the owner of the rice mill and was only a driver of the tractor allegedly involved in the transportation of grains. The case diary, particularly paragraph 50, also described him as the driver of tractor bearing registration number BR-52-8720.
The High Court examined the material collected during investigation and found no evidence indicating that the petitioner was a PDS dealer, agent, rice mill owner or a person entrusted with the stock of PDS grains.
Referring to earlier decisions, the Court observed that prosecution under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act could not be sustained against a person who was not shown to have the relevant connection with the PDS system.
"There is no material to suggest that he was a P.D.S. dealer, agent, owner of the rice mill or a person entrusted with the stock of P.D.S. grains."
The Court also examined the allegations under Sections 409 and 420 IPC. It noted that criminal breach of trust requires entrustment of property and dishonest misappropriation, while cheating requires deception and dishonest inducement. The investigation did not disclose either ingredient against the petitioner.
On the allegation of criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC, the Court held that suspicion or the petitioner's presence as a driver could not, by itself, establish an agreement between him and the other accused persons to commit an illegal act.
"There is no material showing any prior meeting of minds or agreement between the petitioner and the other accused persons for committing the alleged offences."
Applying the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, the High Court held that the material available against the petitioner did not disclose the basic ingredients of the alleged offences.
The Court concluded that continuing the criminal proceedings against him would amount to an abuse of the process of law. Accordingly, it set aside the Magistrate's order dated July 29, 2016, and quashed the criminal proceedings in Sheikhpura P.S. Case No. 161 of 2013 and G.R. Case No. 499 of 2013 qua the petitioner.
The criminal miscellaneous application was allowed.
Case Details
Case Title: Shashi Kant Kumar v. State of Bihar
Case Number: Criminal Miscellaneous No. 38058 of 2016
Judge: Justice Chandra Shekhar Jha
Decision Date: November 18, 202




