The Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has quashed the preventive detention of Ajaz Ahmad Seh under the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978, holding that allegations of communication through an encrypted application and a Virtual Private Network (VPN), without specific supporting material, cannot independently justify such an extraordinary restriction on personal liberty.
Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal allowed the habeas corpus petition and directed the authorities to release Seh forthwith, provided his custody was not required in any other case or under another lawful order.
Background
Seh, a resident of Sehpora in Pulwama district and a driver by profession, was detained on July 28, 2025, under Section 8 of the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978. The order was passed by the District Magistrate, Pulwama, on the basis of a police dossier submitted by the Senior Superintendent of Police.
According to the detention grounds, Seh was allegedly in contact with Aashiq Ahmad Nengroo, described as a terrorist handler affiliated with Jaish-e-Mohammad (JeM), through the encrypted messaging application Zangi and a secured VPN. The authorities also alleged that he worked as an Over Ground Worker (OGW), providing food, shelter, clothing, transportation and information to active terrorists, including Haris Nazir. He was further accused of sharing information about security-force movements and encouraging local youth to join terrorist organisations.
Challenging the detention, Seh argued that the allegations were vague and unsupported by adequate evidence. He also alleged that the District Magistrate had substantially reproduced the police dossier instead of independently examining the material.
The government defended the detention, maintaining that the authority had considered the available material and complied with the constitutional and statutory safeguards.
Justice Nargal emphasised that preventive detention is an extraordinary measure intended to prevent future prejudicial activities, not to punish a person for alleged past conduct. The Court said that serious allegations alone cannot justify detention when the grounds do not disclose sufficient factual details.
Examining the record, the Court found no clear particulars about the dates of the alleged communications, the information exchanged or the specific acts through which logistical assistance was supposedly provided.
The Court observed:
“The mere assertion that the detenue used an encrypted application or a VPN, or remained in contact with persons alleged to be associated with terrorist organisations, cannot, without further particulars and relevant supporting material, furnish an adequate basis for curtailing personal liberty through preventive detention.”
The Court further noted that if the investigating agency possessed evidence of electronic communications being used to coordinate terrorist activities or share information about security-force movements, it could investigate the allegations and proceed under applicable criminal laws, including the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, if its legal requirements were satisfied.
Another significant issue was the similarity between the police dossier and the detention grounds. The Court found that the District Magistrate had substantially reproduced the police allegations without adequately demonstrating independent consideration of the material.
Referring to its earlier ruling in Noor-ud-Din Shah v. State of J&K & Ors., the Court reiterated that the detaining authority must independently assess the facts before exercising its powers.
It also clarified:
“The requirement of subjective satisfaction is not fulfilled merely by reproducing the allegations in the form of grounds of detention; it must reflect due application of mind to the material and the necessity of invoking the extraordinary power conferred by the Act.”
The Court stressed that the seriousness of allegations involving terrorist organisations was not being minimised. However, protection of State security must remain within the limits of law, and personal liberty cannot be curtailed without following the required legal safeguards.
Finding that the detention order suffered from material legal infirmities, the High Court allowed the petition and quashed the District Magistrate's detention order dated July 28, 2025.
The Court directed the authorities to release Ajaz Ahmad Seh forthwith, provided his custody was not required in connection with any other case or under another lawful order.
Case Details
Case Title: Ajaz Ahmad Seh v. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir & Anr.
Case Number: HCP 279/2025
Judge: Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal
Decision Date: 30 October 2026




