Logo

Widow Cannot Lose Inherited Property Rights Due to Subsequent Relationship: MP High Court

Shivam
Add Court Book as a preferred source on Google

Madhya Pradesh High Court upholds a widow's one-third property share, ruling that her subsequent relationship cannot extinguish inheritance rights already vested after her husband's death. - Sahaba @ Sahab & Ors. v. Smt. Savitri & Ors.

Widow Cannot Lose Inherited Property Rights Due to Subsequent Relationship: MP High Court

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has upheld a widow's right to a one-third share in her deceased husband's property, ruling that her subsequent relationship with another man could not take away inheritance rights that had already vested in her.

Justice Pranay Verma, deciding a second appeal, held that a widow who was entitled to inherit her husband's estate at the time of his death could not be deprived of that property merely because she started living with another man several years later.

Background

The dispute concerned agricultural land originally belonging to Sadhuwa, who had four sons: Gopaliya, Lalli, Saheba and Ramshel.

The plaintiff, Savitri, was initially married to Gopaliya, who died without children in 1950. Following his death, she started living with his brother Lalli as his wife according to prevailing caste customs. They had a daughter together.

Court Book subscription: bare acts, legal drafts, court judgments and ad-free legal news, plans from ₹30/month

After Lalli's death, Savitri started living with another brother, Saheba. She claimed that she had inherited a one-third share in Lalli's property and that her name was also recorded in the revenue records.

However, the defendants challenged her claim, arguing that she had subsequently married Saheba and could not continue claiming inheritance as Lalli's widow.

Both the trial court and the first appellate court ruled in Savitri's favour, prompting the defendants to approach the High Court.

The High Court examined whether Savitri's relationship with Saheba legally changed her status as Lalli's widow.

The Court noted that Saheba's first wife, Kamli, was alive when Savitri allegedly started living with him. The defendants had neither pleaded nor established that Saheba had divorced Kamli according to the applicable caste customs.

The Court observed:

"Admittedly, plaintiff had married Lalli, upon whose death she became his widow. Though the defendants contended that thereafter she started living with Saheba as his wife, hence is entitled to claim share in the suit land only to the extent of share of Saheba but from the record and particularly the admissions made by the witnesses of the defendants, it is clear that when plaintiff allegedly started living with Saheba as his wife, another wife of Saheba namely; Kamli, was alive. There is no plea or proof by the defendants that Saheba had divorced Kamli according to caste customs."

The Court held that since Saheba's earlier marriage had not been shown to have been dissolved, his alleged marriage with Savitri could not be treated as legally valid. She therefore continued to be recognised as Lalli's widow.

The Court also considered the argument that Savitri's subsequent relationship made her ineligible to inherit Lalli's property.

Referring to Paragraph 96 of Mulla's Hindu Law, 25th Edition, Justice Verma explained that a widow's chastity was relevant at the time of her husband's death under the Hindu law applicable before the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. However, subsequent unchastity could not divest an estate that had already vested in her.

The Court observed:

"At the time when Lalli had expired, the plaintiff was not living with Saheba, meaning thereby that she was not unchaste at the time of his death. As per the defendants themselves, she started residing with Saheba after a few years of death of Lalli, meaning thereby that her unchastity was after death of Lalli and not at the time of his death."

It further held that Savitri had initially inherited the property as a limited owner, but became its absolute owner after the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, came into force.

Finding no illegality or perversity in the concurrent findings of the lower courts, the High Court answered both substantial questions of law against the defendants.

Accordingly, Justice Pranay Verma dismissed the second appeal and upheld Savitri's entitlement to a one-third share in the disputed land. The Court made no order as to costs.

Case Details

Case Title: Sahaba @ Sahab & Ors. v. Smt. Savitri & Ors.

Case Number: Second Appeal No. 2 of 1994

Judge: Justice Pranay Verma

Decision Date: 2 November 2026

PDF
Download Judgment
Free access
Open PDF

Take CourtBook Everywhere

Access your account on the go with our mobile app.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store
Join the Court Book WhatsApp channel for latest judgments, notifications, legal news and exam updates