The Jharkhand High Court has held that a wife's preference for independent accommodation cannot automatically be treated as matrimonial cruelty. The Court observed that a demand for separate residence must be examined in the context of the parties' circumstances, family responsibilities and the manner in which such a demand was made.
A Division Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava dismissed a husband's appeal challenging the Family Court's refusal to grant him divorce on the grounds of cruelty and desertion under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
Background
The parties married on November 25, 2007, in Arrah, Bihar, and have two daughters. Their matrimonial relationship subsequently became strained over disagreements concerning family arrangements, the husband's elderly father and the wife's preference for separate accommodation.
The husband alleged that his wife objected to living in a joint family, repeatedly quarrelled with him, physically assaulted him and subjected him to mental harassment. He also claimed that she left the matrimonial home with their daughters in May 2017 and later refused to resume normal matrimonial life.
Earlier, the husband had initiated proceedings for restitution of conjugal rights under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act. The matter was subsequently settled through mediation in Ranchi. Following the settlement, the couple stayed in rented accommodation at Singh More.
However, their differences continued. The husband eventually filed Original Suit No. 478 of 2020 seeking divorce under Sections 13(1)(ia) and 13(1)(ib) of the Act.
On May 2, 2025, the Principal Judge, Family Court, Ranchi, dismissed the divorce petition. The husband subsequently approached the High Court.
Examining the allegations, the Bench emphasised that a preference for independent residence cannot, by itself, establish matrimonial cruelty.
The Court observed:
"In this regard, it is necessary to distinguish between a spouse’s unreasonable conduct and a demand for separate residence which may arise from the circumstances of the matrimonial relationship. A spouse’s preference for independent accommodation cannot, in every case, be treated as cruelty. The surrounding circumstances, the needs of the parties, their obligations towards dependent family members, and the manner in which the demand was made must all be considered."
The Bench also noted that the husband had admitted arranging rented accommodation after the mediation proceedings. His admission that he stopped paying rent in April 2019, after the wife's parents began residing with her, was also considered relevant.
On the allegations of physical and mental harassment, the Court found that several serious claims lacked sufficient supporting evidence. The husband had also admitted that he could not produce documentary evidence regarding the alleged consumption of sleeping pills by his wife.
The Bench further clarified that filing a criminal complaint against a spouse does not automatically amount to matrimonial cruelty. The circumstances surrounding the complaint and evidence establishing knowingly false allegations must also be examined.
On desertion, the Court explained that merely living separately for a considerable period is insufficient. The spouse seeking divorce must establish that the other party abandoned the matrimonial relationship without reasonable cause and intended to permanently end cohabitation.
The Court observed:
"The fact that the parties have remained separated for a considerable period cannot, by itself, entitle the appellant-husband to a decree of divorce under Section 13(1)(ib) of the Act, 1955. The statutory requirement is not merely prolonged separation but desertion as understood in matrimonial law."
Finding no illegality or perversity in the Family Court's assessment of the evidence, the Division Bench refused to interfere with its judgment.
Accordingly, the Jharkhand High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the Family Court's judgment dated May 2, 2025, and decree signed on May 16, 2025, refusing to grant divorce.




