The Delhi High Court has held that the applicable stamp duty on an agreement signed by parties in different States cannot be determined merely by identifying where the first signature was placed. The Court emphasised that the nature of the transaction and its real territorial connection must be considered while deciding which State's stamp legislation applies.
In a significant ruling concerning loan agreements between Zee Group companies and Religare Finvest Limited, the Court held that the agreements were executed in Delhi and would therefore be governed by the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, as applicable in the National Capital Territory of Delhi.
Background
The dispute arose from four loan agreements dated March 15, 2014, executed between companies belonging to the Zee Group and Religare Finvest Limited. The lender had extended separate loan facilities to the borrower companies.
The agreements were initially signed by the borrower companies in Mumbai. Religare subsequently signed them in New Delhi on the same day. Each agreement carried stamp duty of ₹100 under the Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958. Religare also deposited an additional ₹1,000 under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, for each agreement.
When repayment disputes led to arbitration proceedings, the parties disagreed over which legislation governed the agreements. The Zee Group maintained that the Maharashtra Stamp Act applied but argued that the agreements attracted stamp duty at 0.2% of the loan amount. Religare, on the other hand, contended that the Indian Stamp Act applicable in Delhi governed the documents.
The sole arbitrator had ruled in February 2026 that the Maharashtra Stamp Act applied and that the agreements were sufficiently stamped with ₹100 each. Both sides challenged the interim arbitral award before the High Court under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
Justice Om Prakash Shukla examined whether the location of the first signature could automatically determine the applicable stamp legislation, particularly when an agreement required signatures from multiple parties situated in different States.
The Court observed that modern commercial agreements are frequently executed electronically, making the physical location of a signatory an unreliable basis for determining stamp duty liability.
It observed:
"In the present digital economy, parties are no longer required to be physically present at a common location for execution of an instrument. An agreement may be negotiated and/or finalised entirely within one State, while a contracting party may electronically sign the same instrument from another State merely because of temporary travel or incidental presence. This Court is of the considered opinion that if the geographical location of the first physical signature is treated as conclusively determining the applicable State legislation of a particular State, the consequence would be that liability of stamp duty could vary solely according to the accidental location of the first signatory to a multilateral agreement."
The Court further clarified that the nature of the document and the requirements for completing its execution must be examined rather than relying exclusively on the sequence of signatures.
On the territorial connection required for imposing stamp duty, the Court observed:
"The raison d’être is that territorial jurisdiction to impose taxation should ordinarily be founded upon a real and meaningful connection between the stamping State and the instrument sought to be stamped, whereas execution may separately serve as the event determining when such liability crystallizes."
Applying these principles, the Court noted that the loan agreements required signatures from both the borrowers and the lender. The borrowers' signatures in Mumbai alone did not complete the agreements. They became executed instruments when Religare signed them in Delhi.
The Court also examined the Facility Schedule of Terms, which specified the loan amounts and formed an integral part of the loan agreements. It found that the arbitrator had overlooked relevant contractual provisions treating these schedules as part of the agreements.
The Court concluded:
"Although the borrowers had initially appended their signatures in Mumbai, in the considered opinion of this Court, such signatures do not, by themselves, constitute the completed chargeable instruments without execution of the instrument by the lender. Accordingly, the requisite connection between the taxable event and the taxing jurisdiction arose in Delhi."
The Delhi High Court held that the loan agreements dated March 15, 2014, were executed in Delhi and would be governed by the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, as applicable in the National Capital Territory of Delhi.
Accordingly, the Court set aside the interim arbitral award dated February 28, 2026. It allowed Religare Finvest Limited's four petitions and dismissed the four petitions filed by the Zee Group companies.
No order as to costs was passed.




