The Supreme Court has directed the Central Bank of India to pay an additional ₹5 lakh to a retired employee who spent decades fighting legal proceedings over his suspension and unpaid service benefits. The Court exercised its powers under Article 142 of the Constitution to bring the long-standing dispute to an end.
Background
The case arose from the suspension of Ashok Kumar, who joined the Central Bank of India on March 1, 1969. He was suspended on November 22, 1978, following allegations of financial irregularities. Criminal proceedings were initiated against him, but he was acquitted by the trial court on July 15, 1983. The challenge to his acquittal was subsequently dismissed by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in 1991.
Despite the acquittal, the Bank initiated departmental proceedings against him in 1990. Kumar challenged the proceedings before the High Court, which quashed the departmental inquiry on October 12, 2007, directing his reinstatement, if he had not reached retirement age, along with consequential benefits.
The Bank challenged the decision, but its appeal before the High Court and subsequent special leave petition before the Supreme Court were unsuccessful. Meanwhile, Kumar retired on March 31, 2009, while still under suspension.
Following contempt proceedings, the Bank paid him approximately ₹42 lakh in December 2011, including his outstanding service benefits.
Kumar subsequently approached the High Court seeking interest on the delayed payment of his salary arrears. However, his writ petition was dismissed in December 2023 on the ground that he had not claimed interest in the original proceedings.
He then filed a miscellaneous application in his earlier writ petition, seeking 18% annual compounded interest. The Single Judge dismissed the application, and the Division Bench upheld that decision in May 2024.
Aggrieved by the dismissal, Kumar approached the Supreme Court.
A Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu examined whether Kumar's claim for interest could be treated as barred by the principles of constructive res judicata, considering that it had not been raised in the original writ petition.
The Court observed that the claim for interest arose from subsequent events, particularly the delay in concluding the judicial proceedings and releasing the financial benefits.
The judgment explained:
"The claim for interest did not arise from the same cause of action which triggered the earlier writ petition but was part of a separate cause of action that arose by virtue of the delay in conclusion of judicial proceedings from the order dated 12th October, 2007, ending with this Court’s order dated 26th July, 2011."
The Court also clarified that a miscellaneous application cannot be used to seek substantive relief based on an independent cause of action after the main proceedings have been finally decided.
It noted that Kumar should have challenged the dismissal of his subsequent writ petition through an intra-court appeal rather than filing a miscellaneous application in the earlier proceedings.
However, the Bench also observed that the High Court should have considered his interest claim on its merits instead of rejecting it on the ground that it was barred.
The Court further noted:
"It is here that we are reminded of the salutary principle that an act of court should harm no litigant."
Considering the prolonged litigation, Kumar's age and the circumstances of the case, the Supreme Court exercised its powers under Article 142 of the Constitution.
The Bench directed the Central Bank of India to pay an additional ₹5 lakh to Ashok Kumar, observing that this amount would sufficiently serve the ends of justice and constitute full and final settlement of his dues against the Bank.
The payment was directed to be made within two months from the date a copy of the judgment is produced before the Bank's competent authority.
The appeal was accordingly disposed of.




